Is your doctor judging you?

Is your doctor judging you?
We expect doctors to give us the absolute best care. But, are they? In a recent poll, One Drop users (29%) said a doctor's advice has been the most beneficial to their health. This was rated second to the helpfulness of One Drop or another health app (39%). Kudos to mobile health! [caption id="attachment_14373" align="alignnone" width="2500"] Based on 349 votes from the One Drop Community. (Based on a combination of One Drop user activity, expected participation in the polls, a confidence level of 95% and a 5% margin of error, the recommended sample size is 323 to have statistical power to say something meaningful. With data on 349 users, we've exceeded that.)[/caption]   My family gets their care at an academic medical center. My former co-workers are our doctors. These doctors know me. They know I'm educated. They use a lot of medical jargon and explain stuff in detail. I can't help but wonder if the next patient is getting the same level of care, or if that care is delivered in the same way.

People aren't treated equally, and their health pays the price

Although people are living longer, certain groups continue to have worse health than others. In diabetes, I've studied and found that, compared to Whites with diabetes, non-Whites with diabetes are much less likely to be prescribed antidepressants if they're depressed, take their medications, and/or have more diabetes-related complications, among other things... Doctors' biases about certain types of patients can lead to disparities in care, treatment, and ultimately: health. A 2016 survey of U.S. physicians found that 2 out of 5 judge their patients. Doctors of all specialties report judging, but more emergency room (ER) doctors admit to doing this than other types of doctors. Such judgments affect the quality and type of care doctors give. For example, in one study, ER doctors were less likely to give Black patients pain medication compared to White patients with the same symptoms.

How do doctors judge?

Doctors are most likely to judge patients:
  1. with emotional problems
  2. who are overweight
  3. who appear uneducated
Doctors also judge patients based on their:
  • language proficiency
  • insurance status
  • age
  • incomes
  • race
  • level of attractiveness
  • gender
And, in that order...

Diabetes doctors judge too

An estimated 31% of diabetes specialists and endocrinologists admit to judging their patients. Doctors who fall into the trap of treating “that fat guy with diabetes” instead of “the guy with diabetes who happens to be overweight” are probably not giving the best care.

Here's what you can do if you feel like you're being judged:

Get educated. Go online to learn about your doctor and what he or she has recommended for you. Make sure they're both a good fit. Ask questions during your doctor's visit. It says you're informed. Doctors are more likely to think twice about how their treatment decisions apply to you when you're an empowered patient. Ask:
  • "How am I doing compared to my last visit?"
  • "What can I do to improve?"
  • "Do you need to change my medications?"
Ask around. Talk to people like you about their experiences.
  • If you're Black or Hispanic, find a doctor with a track record of working well with diverse patients.
  • If you're overweight or obese, ask friends, family or co-workers with similar body types how their doctors treat them.
  • You can also find empathetic doctors through this list or by asking the office staff if a doctor is "size-sensitive.”
Speak up. Before ditching your doctor, consider talking to him or her about what made you uncomfortable. It's empowering to clear the air and establish how you'd like to be treated. It also helps doctors be more self-aware, so they don't treat others that way. Listen to your gut. If you feel like your doctor's judging you, get a second opinion. If it continues, find another doctor. And interview your doctors before committing to them.

The best doctors don't judge

The very best doctors don't care about the 'what' or 'who' of each patient. Withholding judgement is an art. It's not natural our easy for doctors to do, or anyone for that fact. Doctors have a ongoing challenge and opportunity to improve, not just in the type of care they give, but in the art of how its given. Everyone deserves the best care. You do too!
Link copied to the clipboard. ×
Chandra Y. Osborn, PhD, MPH
Oct 17, 2016

Additional Reading


This is H6

Read more >
diabetes hypertension - diabetes and hypertension - diabetes type 2 high blood pressure - high blood pressure and type 2 diabetes - high blood pressure and diabetes - diabetes and high blood pressure - relationship between high blood pressure and diabetes

5 Steps for Treating High Blood Pressure With Diabetes

What is hypertension? // The link between diabetes and hypertension // 5 at-home treatments Diabetes and hypertension (high blood pressure) have common risk factors and often occur...

Read more >
Visit our store

Gorgeous gear. Supplies shipped to your door. On-demand support from diabetes experts.

Shop Now